'Nationalism'
trumps unions - The Nation,
May 12, 2005
A labour journal article has outlined the main
issues preventing Thai workers from forming labour unions, chief
among them that nation's image supersedes their needs for better
working conditions.
Labour Focus, a quarterly labour journal published by the non-governmental
organisation Campaign for Thai Labour Programme, also cited other
factors such as rhetoric that factories are extended families and
that "Thai-ness" is being held up as an antithesis to
collective bargaining. The article is the result of a survey of
union leaders and workers over recent years.
Other perceived obstacles are threats of factory relocation abroad,
especially to countries with cheaper labour like Vietnam, China
and Indonesia, the slow and costly process of labour court hearings,
and claims by employees that they already have adequate ethical
standards...
[2015 note: Like many Thai newspaper articles from the early days of the Thai internet, this article is no longer online. Below is the complete text of the original article.]
'Nationalism' trumps unions
Published on May 12 , 2005
A labour journal article has outlined the main issues preventing Thai workers from forming labour unions, chief among them that nation's image supersedes their needs for better working conditions.
Labour Focus, a quarterly labour journal published by the non-governmental organisation Campaign for Thai Labour Programme, also cited other factors such as rhetoric that factories are extended families and that "Thai-ness" is being held up as an antithesis to collective bargaining. The article is the result of a survey of union leaders and workers over recent years.
Other perceived obstacles are threats of factory relocation abroad, especially to countries with cheaper labour like Vietnam, China and Indonesia, the slow and costly process of labour court hearings, and claims by employees that they already have adequate ethical standards.
The findings, compiled by labour activist and editor of the journal, Janya Yimprasert, state that employers often advise their workers - with considerable success - to think about the nation's image before organising or staging a strike for better working conditions.
"Employers also use the word 'family' when abuse of workers' rights takes place, or when they want to persuade employees against fighting for their rights under the law," the journal says.
Another grey area is reference to "Thai-ness" as being essentially incompatible with collective bargaining through unionism and strikes, the journal states, and argues: "When trading is already borderless, labour rights deserve to be recognised through universal standards as well. Employers willingly compete in world markets by insisting on 'Asian values' to suppress their workforce."
Another rhetorical issue that gains widespread acceptance in a country where only 3 per cent of the workforce is unionised is that fighting for labour rights may lead to factory relocation, the journal says.
"Some members of Parliament, even some members of the National Human Rights Commission and union leaders themselves, still believe that when Thai workers demand their legal rights, employers will simply shift their production to China or Vietnam. Thus they reason that workers should just 'cope with whatever work conditions exist'."
With low minimum wages of Bt135 to Bt175 a day, the journal argues that many Thai workers end up having to work overtime for an average of three to 10 hours a day just to make ends meet.
This, it states, runs contrary to the ideal of eight hours of work, eight hours of recreation and eight hours of sleep enjoyed by many workers in the West," the journal noted.
2Bangkok: Recommended by roughguides.com

Last Century
The Tales of an Adventurer in the Asian Tiger Era
Hardback | Kindle
Like 2Bangkok on Facebook
2Bangkok on Twitter

1 Year Ago Today
- 2020-01-24 No articles on this date.
2 Years Ago Today
3 Years Ago Today
4 Years Ago Today
5 Years Ago Today
6 Years Ago Today
- 2015-01-24 No articles on this date.
7 Years Ago Today
- Thai police: US tourist likely killed by elephants
- More mentions of the secret CIA prison in Thailand
- Poor leadership: Thailand Is Only the Tip of Asia’s Iceberg
- The Economist: Thailand’s very unity is now under threat
- Thai Protesters Create Mercedes Logo Instead of Peace Symbol
- Why do they all run... when we light candles?
- Thai police: US tourist likely killed by elephants
8 Years Ago Today
9 Years Ago Today
- Thailand seeks political solution to insurgency
ประเทศไทยค้นหาการแก้ไขการจลาจลทางการเมือง - Family calls for Thailand drug smuggler to be released
ครอบครัวบอกให้ปล่อยผู้ลักลอบขนยาเข้าประเทศไทย - Sumatra elephant faces extinction in 30 years: WWF
ช้างที่เกาะสุมาตรากำลังจะสูญพันธุ์ในอีก 30 ปี - Thai Govt Will Not Meddle in Dawei Dispute
รัฐบาลไทยจะไม่ยุ่งเกี่ยวกับการโต้เถียงที่ดาไว - Three dead in Suphan Buri fireworks
มี 3 คนเสียชีวิตในเหตุการณ์พลุระเบิดที่สุพรรณ - Thai-language Headlines of January 24, 2012
- Happy New Year from All of Us in Chonburi
สุขสันต์วันปีใหม่จากเราทุกคนที่ชลบุรี - Nine Years Ago: The Kra Isthmus Canal
9 ปีที่แล้ว : คอคอดกระ - 2011, the Year of Rabbit Hunting
2011 ปีแห่งการล่ากระต่าย - Give in to Beer and Sexy Ladies
ส่งเบียร์ไปให้กับสาวเซ็กซี่
- Thailand seeks political solution to insurgency
10 Years Ago Today

Recent Comments
- Surabot Panich-chonkai on Cracking open the Crown Property Bureau
- RametinNonta on What is happening in America?
- Ghafar Aliwardana on Different tactics
- Thai Bridge – A proposed sea bridge across the Bay of Bangkok on The 50 kilometer bridge over the Gulf of Thailand
- Wisarut on Those young bloods… please follow me
- I am Putin on Those young bloods… please follow me
Categories
- 1991 Coup
- 2004 Tsunami
- 2006 Coup
- 2014 Coup
- 2Bangkok
- 2Bangkok News
- A Tale of Two Newspapers
- Advertising and Commercials
- Airports and Airlines
- Analysis
- Announcements
- Anti-Americanism
- Art
- Best of 2Bangkok
- Black May 1992
- Books
- Border Issues
- Bridges
- Buddhism
- Buildings
- Buses
- Business
- Cambodia
- Censorship
- Chalerm Yubamrung
- Chavalit Yongchaiyudh
- China
- Christmas
- Chulalongkorn Day
- Chuwit Kamolvisit
- Communities
- Community Radio
- Crime
- Culture and Society
- Deep South Violence Statistics
- Dhammakaya Movement
- Drugs
- Economy
- Editorial Cartoons
- Editorial Cartoons – Daily News
- Editorial Cartoons – Komchadluek
- Editorial Cartoons – Manager
- Editorial Cartoons – Naewna
- Editorial Cartoons – Stephff
- Editorial Cartoons – Thairath – Chai
- Editorial Cartoons – Thairath – Sia
- Editorial Cartoons – Various
- Editorial Cartoons – Arun
- Elections
- Energy
- Errors
- Falling
- Film and TV
- Floods
- Food and Drink
- Gem Scam
- Giant Swing – Sao Ching Cha
- Graffiti
- Health
- High Tension in Thailand 2004-2008
- High Tension in Thailand 2011
- Highways and Roads
- History
- HIV-AIDS
- HM The King's Birthday
- HM The Queen's Birthday
- Human Rights
- Humor
- India
- Infrastructure
- Intellectual Property/Piracy
- International Events
- Journalism
- Kamronwit Thoopkrachang
- Labor
- Language
- Laos
- Law
- Local Beliefs
- Loy Krathong
- Malaysia
- Maps
- Mass Transit
- Master Plans
- Music
- Myanmar/Burma
- Navin
- New Year's Cartoons
- New Year's Eve
- New Year's Eve
- New Year's Eve Bombings in Bangkok
- News and Views
- North Korea
- Nothing to do with Thailand, but Interesting
- October, 1973
- October, 1976
- Old newspapers
- Old photos and films
- Pattaya
- People
- Polls
- Preah Vihear
- Property and Development
- Protest
- Rare Animals
- Red Shirt Protest 2009
- Red Shirt Protest 2010
- Refugees and Migrants
- Robert Amsterdam
- Scams
- Security
- Signs and Billboards
- Singapore
- Skytrain
- Skytrain
- Songkran
- Sports
- Stephff's Cartoons
- Subway
- Technology
- Terrorism
- Thai Email Forwards
- Thai Holidays and Festivals
- Thai Media Project
- Thai Military
- Thai newspaper headlines
- Thai Newspapers and Magazines
- Thai Police
- Thai Politics
- Thai Railroads
- Thai Secret Prison
- Thai-language Newspaper Headlines
- Thailand in the International Media
- Thaksin Amnesty
- Thaksin Lobbying
- Thaksin's War on Drugs
- Tharit Pengdit
- The Mahakan Fort Community
- The Monarchy
- The Philippines
- The Rama VIII Bridge
- The Simpsons in Thailand
- The Thai Deep South
- The Thaksin Years
- Today in History
- Tourism
- Trams
- Uncategorized
- Vietnam
- Weather
- Wikileaks
- Wildlife and Nature
